079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

March 18, 2025

Ready for
an algorithm-proof
marketing strategy?

WATCH VIDEO

TOP categories

All the best business advice in one convenient place.

Give me 15 minutes, and I'll give you a marketing strategy that works.

Mama of four, business builder, and lover of bold ideas. I’m here to share the behind-the-scenes of building businesses, launching what lights me up, and creating a life that feels aligned every step of the way.

Hey, I'm Elena

my story

If you’ve been relying solely on organic marketing—posting on social media, hoping for engagement, and waiting for website visitors to show up—you’ve likely felt the highs and lows of unpredictable traffic. One day, your content reaches hundreds (maybe thousands) of people; the next, it barely makes a ripple.

The reality? Organic traffic alone isn’t enough.

  • The average organic reach for a Facebook post is just 6.4% of your total followers (Invoca).
  • On Instagram, engagement rates have dropped significantly as competition for visibility increases (The Graygency).
  • Pinterest, while still a strong organic traffic driver, requires consistent content creation to maintain visibility.

So what does this mean for your business? If you’re relying on organic marketing alone, you’re leaving potential customers on the table. That’s where paid advertising—especially on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest—fills in the gaps.

How Paid Ads Solve the Organic Reach Problem

1. They Guarantee Visibility

Instead of hoping your audience sees your posts, ads put your content directly in front of the right people. Whether it’s a warm audience (people who have engaged with your brand before) or a cold audience (new potential customers), ads ensure your content gets seen.

Think about it: social media algorithms are unpredictable, constantly changing, and making it harder for businesses to be seen. But when you run ads, you take control of who sees your message. No more hoping your post magically gets engagement—ads ensure that your best content lands in front of the exact audience you want to reach.

2. They Target Your Ideal Customers

Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest offer incredibly detailed targeting options. You’re not just randomly throwing content into the void and hoping it sticks—you’re strategically choosing who sees your ads based on:

  • Demographics (age, gender, location, income level)
  • Interests & behaviors (shopping habits, pages they follow, searches they make)
  • Past interactions (people who have visited your site, engaged with your content, or even abandoned their cart!)

Instead of wasting money reaching people who have no interest in what you offer, you’re getting in front of the exact people who are already looking for a solution like yours. This means higher conversion rates, better engagement, and a more efficient ad spend.

3. They Create Consistent Traffic & Sales

One of the biggest struggles with organic marketing is inconsistency. Some weeks are booming, while others are painfully slow.

Paid ads remove that rollercoaster effect. When done right, they create a steady flow of high-quality traffic to your site. And the best part? That traffic is predictable.

Imagine waking up every morning to new leads, sales, and inquiries—without having to post, engage, or scramble to create last-minute content. That’s the power of paid advertising.

4. They Provide Measurable Results

With paid advertising, you’re not guessing what’s working. Every ad campaign comes with detailed analytics that allow you to track:

  • Click-through rates (CTR) – How many people are actually engaging with your ad?
  • Conversion rates – How many of those clicks turn into actual sales or sign-ups?
  • Return on investment (ROI) – For every $1 you spend, how much are you making back?

This data means you can fine-tune your strategy, scaling what works and eliminating what doesn’t. Unlike organic content, where it’s hard to know exactly what’s driving conversions, ads make it crystal clear.

How to Get Started with Ads (Without Wasting Money)

If you’re new to paid advertising, the key is to start strategically and avoid common pitfalls. Here’s a step-by-step approach:

Step 1: Set Clear Goals

Before running ads, ask yourself:

  • Do I want more website traffic?
  • Do I need to generate leads?
  • Am I looking to increase direct sales?

Knowing your goal helps you create an effective ad strategy rather than throwing money at random campaigns.

Step 2: Choose the Right Platform

Each platform serves different audiences and purposes:

Facebook & Instagram Ads

Think of these as your go-to for precise targeting and immediate engagement. You can get really specific about who sees your ads—choosing things like age, location, interests, and even past interactions with your business. These ads are perfect when you want people to take action right away, whether that’s making a purchase, signing up for your email list, or engaging with your content.

Pinterest Ads

Pinterest works a little differently—and in the best way possible. Unlike Facebook and Instagram, where people scroll to be entertained, Pinterest users are actively searching for ideas, products, and solutions. That means when your ad appears, it’s not an interruption—it’s a helpful answer to what they were already looking for.

And here’s what makes it even better: your ad doesn’t just disappear after the campaign ends. Because Pinterest is a search engine, your promoted pins can continue working for months (even years) after you stop running them. If you’re brand new to ads, Pinterest is the easiest place to start because your ad is landing in front of people who are already interested in what you have to offer—no convincing required.

Step 3: Start Small and Test

You don’t need a huge budget to start seeing results. Begin with a low daily budget ($5-$10) and test different audiences, ad formats, and messaging. Monitor what works before scaling your budget.

Step 4: Optimize for Conversions

Once you have data, tweak your campaigns by:

  • Refining your target audience.
  • Testing different ad creatives (images, videos, or carousels).
  • Adjusting your ad copy for clarity and urgency.

Step 5: Leverage Remarketing Ads

One of the most powerful strategies in paid ads is remarketing. These are ads targeted at people who have already engaged with your content or visited your site but didn’t convert. These audiences are warmer and much more likely to buy.

Example: The other day, I spent $11 on a remarketing ad and made $470 in return. This isn’t the case every single day, but it highlights how remarketing delivers the best ROI because you’re targeting people already interested in what you offer.

The Missing Piece in Your Marketing Strategy

If your business is experiencing inconsistent growth, it might be time to add paid advertising into your strategy. Ads provide a predictable way to drive traffic, generate leads, and increase revenue.

And if you’re ready to take it to the next level, my Pinterest Ad Strategy Course breaks down everything you need to know to run profitable ads without wasting money. It’s a 90-minute training that walks you through exactly how I set up, test, and optimize my campaigns. (Check it out here)

Paid advertising isn’t a magic solution, but it is a powerful tool when used strategically. The key is to test, refine, and stay consistent.

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

Read the latest posts

what's new

DOWNLOADED OVER 52,000 TIMES! The official Business Planner every business owner needs to have. Our goal was to have a printable planner that is beautiful, functional, and inspirational for business owners. 

FREE PRINTABLE BUSINESS PLANNER

INSTANT DOWNLOADS

Coming soon!

COMING SOON!

INSTANT DOWNLOADS

my story

I’ve built brands from the ground up, sold software, launched tools like Wordsmith and taught thousands how to run ads that actually convert. I care about building businesses that create freedom — not burnout — and I’m here to help you do the same. Strategy, simplicity, and a whole lot of heart.

Big Goals, Smart Strategy, and a Business Bestie Who Knows What Works

Reply...

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

If you’ve been relying solely on organic marketing—posting on social media, hoping for engagement, and waiting for website visitors to show up—you’ve likely felt the highs and lows of unpredictable traffic. One day, your content reaches hundreds (maybe thousands) of people; the next, it barely makes a ripple.

The reality? Organic traffic alone isn’t enough.

The average organic reach for a Facebook post is just 6.4% of your total followers (Invoca).

On Instagram, engagement rates have dropped significantly as competition for visibility increases (The Graygency).

Pinterest, while still a strong organic traffic driver, requires consistent content creation to maintain visibility.

So what does this mean for your business? If you’re relying on organic marketing alone, you’re leaving potential customers on the table. That’s where paid advertising—especially on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest—fills in the gaps.

How Paid Ads Solve the Organic Reach Problem

1. They Guarantee Visibility

Instead of hoping your audience sees your posts, ads put your content directly in front of the right people. Whether it’s a warm audience (people who have engaged with your brand before) or a cold audience (new potential customers), ads ensure your content actuallygets seen.

2. They Target Your Ideal Customers

Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest offer detailed targeting options, allowing you to reach people based on demographics, interests, behaviors, and even past interactions with your brand. This means you’re not just reaching more people—you’re reaching the right people.

3. They Create Consistent Traffic & Sales

One of the biggest struggles with organic marketing is inconsistency. Some weeks are booming, while others are slow. Paid ads create a steady flow of traffic, bringing potential customers to your website every single day.

4. They Provide Measurable Results

With paid advertising, you’re not guessing what’s working. Every ad campaign comes with detailed insights—click-through rates, conversions, return on investment—so you can see exactly what’s bringing in results and adjust accordingly.

How to Get Started with Ads (Without Wasting Money)

If you’re new to paid advertising, the key is to start strategically and avoid common pitfalls. Here’s a step-by-step approach:

Step 1: Set Clear Goals

Before running ads, ask yourself:

Do I want more website traffic?

Do I need to generate leads?

Am I looking to increase direct sales?

If you’ve been relying solely on organic marketing—posting on social media, hoping for engagement, and waiting for website visitors to show up—you’ve likely felt the highs and lows of unpredictable traffic. One day, your content reaches hundreds (maybe thousands) of people; the next, it barely makes a ripple.

The reality? Organic traffic alone isn’t enough.

The average organic reach for a Facebook post is just 6.4% of your total followers (Invoca).

On Instagram, engagement rates have dropped significantly as competition for visibility increases (The Graygency).

Pinterest, while still a strong organic traffic driver, requires consistent content creation to maintain visibility.

So what does this mean for your business? If you’re relying on organic marketing alone, you’re leaving potential customers on the table. That’s where paid advertising—especially on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest—fills in the gaps.

How Paid Ads Solve the Organic Reach Problem

1. They Guarantee Visibility

Instead of hoping your audience sees your posts, ads put your content directly in front of the right people. Whether it’s a warm audience (people who have engaged with your brand before) or a cold audience (new potential customers), ads ensure your content actuallygets seen.

2. They Target Your Ideal Customers

Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest offer detailed targeting options, allowing you to reach people based on demographics, interests, behaviors, and even past interactions with your brand. This means you’re not just reaching more people—you’re reaching the right people.

3. They Create Consistent Traffic & Sales

One of the biggest struggles with organic marketing is inconsistency. Some weeks are booming, while others are slow. Paid ads create a steady flow of traffic, bringing potential customers to your website every single day.

4. They Provide Measurable Results

With paid advertising, you’re not guessing what’s working. Every ad campaign comes with detailed insights—click-through rates, conversions, return on investment—so you can see exactly what’s bringing in results and adjust accordingly.

How to Get Started with Ads (Without Wasting Money)

If you’re new to paid advertising, the key is to start strategically and avoid common pitfalls. Here’s a step-by-step approach:

Step 1: Set Clear Goals

Before running ads, ask yourself:

Do I want more website traffic?

Do I need to generate leads?

Am I looking to increase direct sales?

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

MODERN MARKET

079: Why I Stopped Relying on Organic Reach

MODERN MARKET

If you’ve been relying solely on organic marketing—posting on social media, hoping for engagement, and waiting for website visitors to show up—you’ve likely felt the highs and lows of unpredictable traffic. One day, your content reaches hundreds (maybe thousands) of people; the next, it barely makes a ripple.

The reality? Organic traffic alone isn’t enough.

The average organic reach for a Facebook post is just 6.4% of your total followers (Invoca).

On Instagram, engagement rates have dropped significantly as competition for visibility increases (The Graygency).

Pinterest, while still a strong organic traffic driver, requires consistent content creation to maintain visibility.

So what does this mean for your business? If you’re relying on organic marketing alone, you’re leaving potential customers on the table. That’s where paid advertising—especially on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest—fills in the gaps.

How Paid Ads Solve the Organic Reach Problem

1. They Guarantee Visibility

Instead of hoping your audience sees your posts, ads put your content directly in front of the right people. Whether it’s a warm audience (people who have engaged with your brand before) or a cold audience (new potential customers), ads ensure your content actuallygets seen.

2. They Target Your Ideal Customers

Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest offer detailed targeting options, allowing you to reach people based on demographics, interests, behaviors, and even past interactions with your brand. This means you’re not just reaching more people—you’re reaching the right people.

3. They Create Consistent Traffic & Sales

One of the biggest struggles with organic marketing is inconsistency. Some weeks are booming, while others are slow. Paid ads create a steady flow of traffic, bringing potential customers to your website every single day.

4. They Provide Measurable Results

With paid advertising, you’re not guessing what’s working. Every ad campaign comes with detailed insights—click-through rates, conversions, return on investment—so you can see exactly what’s bringing in results and adjust accordingly.

How to Get Started with Ads (Without Wasting Money)

If you’re new to paid advertising, the key is to start strategically and avoid common pitfalls. Here’s a step-by-step approach:

Step 1: Set Clear Goals

Before running ads, ask yourself:

Do I want more website traffic?

Do I need to generate leads?

Am I looking to increase direct sales?

If you’ve been relying solely on organic marketing—posting on social media, hoping for engagement, and waiting for website visitors to show up—you’ve likely felt the highs and lows of unpredictable traffic. One day, your content reaches hundreds (maybe thousands) of people; the next, it barely makes a ripple.

The reality? Organic traffic alone isn’t enough.

The average organic reach for a Facebook post is just 6.4% of your total followers (Invoca).

On Instagram, engagement rates have dropped significantly as competition for visibility increases (The Graygency).

Pinterest, while still a strong organic traffic driver, requires consistent content creation to maintain visibility.

So what does this mean for your business? If you’re relying on organic marketing alone, you’re leaving potential customers on the table. That’s where paid advertising—especially on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest—fills in the gaps.

How Paid Ads Solve the Organic Reach Problem

1. They Guarantee Visibility

Instead of hoping your audience sees your posts, ads put your content directly in front of the right people. Whether it’s a warm audience (people who have engaged with your brand before) or a cold audience (new potential customers), ads ensure your content actuallygets seen.

2. They Target Your Ideal Customers

Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest offer detailed targeting options, allowing you to reach people based on demographics, interests, behaviors, and even past interactions with your brand. This means you’re not just reaching more people—you’re reaching the right people.

3. They Create Consistent Traffic & Sales

One of the biggest struggles with organic marketing is inconsistency. Some weeks are booming, while others are slow. Paid ads create a steady flow of traffic, bringing potential customers to your website every single day.

4. They Provide Measurable Results

With paid advertising, you’re not guessing what’s working. Every ad campaign comes with detailed insights—click-through rates, conversions, return on investment—so you can see exactly what’s bringing in results and adjust accordingly.

How to Get Started with Ads (Without Wasting Money)

If you’re new to paid advertising, the key is to start strategically and avoid common pitfalls. Here’s a step-by-step approach:

Step 1: Set Clear Goals

Before running ads, ask yourself:

Do I want more website traffic?

Do I need to generate leads?

Am I looking to increase direct sales?

follow along

It’s not just another newsletter. It’s the one email 100,000+ business owners actually look forward to. Real talk, business tips, and the kind of insider advice you didn’t know you needed —  delivered straight to your inbox.

One Email. Every Week

100,000+ Entrepreneurs Can’t Be Wrong